How to Re-Engage Lapsed Donors with 1 Simple Email


Hey Reader,

Re-engaging lapsed donors can feel daunting, but sometimes all it takes is a simple, thoughtful message to rekindle that connection - and secure their next gift! When donors feel personally appreciated, they’re often open to reconnecting and learning about the impact of their past support. Plus, you can share a recent infographic or your annual report to remind them of the amazing work you're doing.

Here’s a straightforward email template you can use to reach out to lapsed donors, inviting them for a quick call or meeting to catch up on what’s new with your organization:


Subject Line: I'd Love to Reconnect, [DONOR’S NAME]!

Hi [DONOR’S NAME],

I hope you’re doing well! I wanted to reach out personally because your past support for [ORGANIZATION NAME] has made such a difference, and we truly miss having you as part of our community. Your generous contributions have allowed us to [describe specific impact of previous gifts, e.g., “serve more families in need” or “launch essential programs”].

I'd love to reconnect and share some updates on the work you’ve been a part of, as well as where we’re headed next. If you’re open to it, would you be interested in a quick call or a short meeting? It would be wonderful to hear from you and to catch you up on what we’re achieving together.

Thank you again for all you've done for [ORGANIZATION NAME]. I look forward to hopefully speaking soon!

Warm regards,
[YOUR NAME]
[YOUR TITLE]
[ORGANIZATION NAME]

P.S. I've attached our latest annual report - your support helped make all of this possible!


A quick tip: For added personalization, try including specific details of what their past gifts made possible. This makes it easier for them to see the ongoing value of their support.

Try it out and see how it works! Let us know if you have any questions, or feel free to share your experiences—just hit reply.

Cheers,
Kay

Certified Fund Raising Expert (CFRE)
Founder and CEO, NonProfit-Life


PS: If you’re looking to take your fundraising to the next level, here are 3 ways you can do that today:

Kay @ NonProfit Life

I teach nonprofit professionals - over 5,000 and counting! - how to grow their organizations with practical, action-oriented templates and tools. From event sponsorship packages, grant proposals, board orientation handbooks, and everything in between, I focus on helping you save time, effort and precious resources. As a Certified Fund Raising Executive (CFRE), I've raised 25 million+ for other organizations, and now my passion is to help you do the same for yours. Join the weekly newsletter to get time saving tips, tricks and action plans you can implement today to accelerate your nonprofit.

Read more from Kay @ NonProfit Life

Hey Reader, AI is everywhere right now. Your inbox is probably full of promises that it'll solve all your problems. If I'm being honest, I tune out a lot of the emails I get about AI, so I haven't thought to talk about it. But I also use AI in my day to day fundraising, AND I've seen it used horribly in fundraising contexts and completely botch securing a donation. This made me wonder...would YOU find it helpful to learn how to use AI in your day to day fundraising? Answer below and you'll...

Hey Reader, Even though "making the ask" is really just 5% of what you have to do in fundraising, it can feel SO awkward and overwhelming. Trust me, I get it! (Not sure what the remaining 95% is? Reply to this email "95%" and I'll share more!) The truth is, even the best Executive Directors and fundraisers can be tempted to hesitate when it comes time to actually make the ask. Even when you know the value of your work, putting it into words can feel clunky or overly formal. If that’s you—here...

Hey Reader, Most of the time, I focus on the techniques, skills, and "how to's" of fundraising that I have found to be most effective in raising money. There's a LOT of information on the internet about fundraising, and I don't take lightly that you choose to be part of the NonProfit Life community! So I want to make sure my emails are not only practical, but also effective so you don't waste your time or money. But sometimes, you just need a reminder of all the possibilities out there. There...